Book Review

What The Mother Knew, Edmund Tardos

04/10/2008 - 12:00pm

Reviewing true crime books, particularly one that discusses such a recent case, is a complex undertaking.  There are obviously people out there for whom this case is still very raw and who are still dealing with the fallout of a violent death and the associated grief and loss. 

The attraction of true crime books, for me at least, is the chance to assess the events, understand the reality of crime, and maybe understand why the crime happened.  True Crime books often, however, aren't able to explain why.  Perhaps because the offender themselves has never clearly said why - ... Read Review

The Scent of the Night, Andrea Camilleri

03/10/2008 - 6:51pm

A large part of the attraction of these novels is the wonderfully grumpy, slightly eccentric, marvellously self-involved Inspector Montalbano.  And the food - the meals that Montalbano insists on partaking on a regular basis are frankly, almost obscenely fantastic.  Of course, for the books to be completely satisfactory there has actually got to be a story, and as with all these books, the story here is superbly Italian in its feel.  The financier Emanuele Gargano has disappeared - as has a large amount of money that a lot of local retirees invested with him.  An investigation had ... Read Review

The Smell of the Night, Andrea Camilleri

03/10/2008 - 11:32am

A large part of the attraction of these novels is the wonderfully grumpy, slightly eccentric, marvellously self-involved Inspector Montalbano.  And the food - the meals that Montalbano insists on partaking on a regular basis are frankly, almost obscenely fantastic.  Of course, for the books to be completely satisfactory there has actually got to be a story, and as with all these books, the story here is superbly Italian in its feel.  The financier Emanuele Gargano has disappeared - as has a large amount of money that a lot of local retirees invested with him.  An investigation had ... Read Review

Murder on the Brighton Express, Edward Marston

02/10/2008 - 12:59pm

MURDER ON THE BRIGHTON EXPRESS is the fifth in the Railway Detective series and it’s easy to see why the series is popular.  Colbeck is a progressive and broadminded man; a rarity in Victorian times.  It is easy to visualise the Victorian world that the author Edward Marston has chosen for his characters. Marston paints little vignettes of life in England in the mid-nineteenth century through his characters. 

MURDER ON THE BRIGHTON EXPRESS is not going to set the world on fire, but it does offer an engrossing mystery with diverse characters to make for a light, ... Read Review

The Ninth Circle, Alex Bell

01/10/2008 - 1:55pm

Reading THE NINTH CIRCLE was a weird experience and that's not just because the subject matter dipped into the supernatural very quickly.  

THE NINTH CIRCLE is partly a mystery and partly fantasy.  When Gabriel wakes up on his own floor he has no idea who he is, where he is, or where the money came from.  He does have some memories of how to function, how to feed himself, how to go out and slowly discover the more intimate details of his life - it's like his own personal past has been knocked out, yet everything else in the world works.  Slowly, via a series of ... Read Review

Red Centre, Dark Heart, Evan McHugh

01/10/2008 - 1:42pm

This book is absolutely fascinating.  In a series of chapters based on each crime - starting with the escape of convicts in Tasmania in 1822, right through to the disappearance of Peter Falconio in the Northern Territory in 2001, the author has explored a series of notorious crimes - all of which took place in various locations throughout the bush and remote Australian outback.

Starting out with the escape and subsequent cannibalism of a group of convicts in Tasmania in 1822, we then learn how cattle rustling in 1870 is more successful when you are in an area so remote ... Read Review

Maxwell's Point, M.J. Trow

30/09/2008 - 1:42pm

MAXWELL'S POINT is the 12 book in what seems to now be a 14 book series.  Having never read any of the earlier books, I was particularly curious to see whether or not the series could be picked up well down the track without this reader feeling lost, and more than a little confused.  

It did take a few chapters to get used to the sense of humour and the tone of the book.  'Mad Max' is an extremely sarcastic, dryly witty, acerbic sort of a character and the tone and humour is  heavy-handed.  Once you get used to that, and come to understand what the outwardly awkward old ... Read Review

Little White Lies, Ian McFadyen

30/09/2008 - 1:00pm

LITTLE WHITE LIES is a debut novel from Ian McFadyen - drawing on most of the classic elements of the small English village mystery, combined with some elements of a classic police procedural.

Steve and his family have moved away from his big city policing job, to a small village where Penny grew up.  He's taken the position of Chief Inspector in the local town's force, but he wasn't really expecting his first major investigation to be the death of a woman in his own village.  The fact that Penny knows the victim, and all the possible suspects, as they were all at school ... Read Review

The Watchful Eye, Priscilla Masters

22/09/2008 - 3:03pm

Billed as one of Priscilla Masters Medical Mysteries, this author has written around 15 books, some standalone, some with a central series character. THE WATCHFUL EYE is set, as the synopsis says, in a classic small English village where Daniel Gregory is the local GP.  Recently divorced, with a young daughter of his own, he's essentially a lonely man, kept in the village by his house and his job alone.  But he has a rather odd relationship with many of those patients.  Whilst he is concerned by the plight of little Anna-Louise, he does seem a little ineffectual - more worrying than ... Read Review

Stingray, J.R. Carroll

20/09/2008 - 1:45pm

This is an earlier book from J.R. Carroll (although later books are thin on the ground now as well), set in Melbourne, where the discovery of eight bodies in the scrub at Kinglake is only part of what is happening.  This book revolves around the man in charge of that investigation - Kerry Byrne.  It's about him and his mates in the squad.  It's about the problems that police have in staying uninvolved when what they deal with is indescribably horrible, and it's about the difficulties they have with their personal lives.

Sometimes the private life problems are self- ... Read Review

Gospel, Sydney Bauer (review by sunniefromoz)

20/09/2008 - 11:42am

Sydney Bauer’s first book, UNDERTOW was a fast paced thriller and GOSPEL is promoted in the same way.  It doesn’t seem to have quite the same pace and I think it suffers for that.  The first couple of chapters introduce a so many characters that I found it confusing for quite a while.  Bauer’s use of adjectives seemed at times a little unnecessary:  ‘She took  two of the  upturned glasses standing on the crisp white towel  on the black marble counter and poured them both a drink before gliding across the room, extending her long  slender arm and handing him his water.’  It was a very ... Read Review

Fat, Fifty & F***ed! - Geoffrey McGeachin

19/09/2008 - 1:14pm

Martin's the sort of bloke that persons of a certain age can identify with.  It might not make you all that comfortable with yourself, but boy can you identify (I hasten to add I have NEVER worn brown suede shoes and if I ever do .... well feel free to shoot me on sight), but I digress.

Martin's having a bad day - his missus is blatantly and spectacularly unfaithful again, his step kids don't even pretend to be bothered with him and the bank he's loyally worked for for years has just closed his branch and retrenched him.  Perhaps they weren't quite expecting the kind of ... Read Review

The Dying Breed, Declan Hughes

17/09/2008 - 1:25pm

THE DYING BREED is the third book in the Irish PI Ed Loy series from Declan Hughes, Ed being an Irishman who went home after living in the US for many years.  A broken marriage and the tragic death of his young daughter are events that shaped him there, but his childhood in Ireland shaped him even more firmly, and a large number of the characters that he works with on a daily basis are connections from the past.  But he's a PI (in a place where that's still a bit of a novelty) and he's ready for his next case (and pay cheque), so he takes on a very odd investigation in THE DYING BREED ... Read Review

Flawed, Jo Bannister

15/09/2008 - 2:16pm

FLAWED is the seventh in the Brodie Farrell, Daniel Hood and Jack Deacon books, although the blurb doesn't mention Daniel. As I've never read any of this series before, I was a little confused at the start as Daniel (who at that stage was a total unknown as far as I was concerned) takes centre stage in FLAWED, Jack Deacon is bit of a background character, and Brodie Farrell doesn't really get much focus until way later in the book. To add to the slight feeling of discombobulation, there was then a pretty steep learning curve to get to know who these three are and how they all fit ... Read Review

Inside Their Minds, Rochelle Jackson

15/09/2008 - 11:48am

One of the strongest messages you get from a true crime book like INSIDE THEIR MINDS is that no matter how hard we try, no matter how much analysis goes on, there is something about so many of the more notorious criminals in our world that the rest of us will simply never fathom.

Rochelle Jackson looks at some of the most notorious, mass murderer Martin Bryant, sex offender Karen Ellis, serial killer Ivan Milat, serial arsonist Peter Burgess, armed robber and serial escapee Brenden Abbott, child killer Kathleen Folbigg, murdered Matthew Wales and gangland killer Carl ... Read Review

Frantic, Katherine Howell (review by sally906)

14/09/2008 - 1:52pm

Wow - what a great debut thriller - this was a real page turner for me the suspense was unrelenting.

Sophie Phillips is a paramedic in Sydney, Australia. Not only is her work high stress with a non-stop pace - but her home life is just as busy with a baby boy and policeman husband, Chris

The book opens right in the middle of the action - a bank robbery, the seventh in a series, has occurred and a guard is down. Sophie and her partner Mick are called to attend but are unable to save the guard. Almost immediately they are called to the emergency birth of a ... Read Review

A Florentine Death, Michele Giuttari

12/09/2008 - 1:58pm

Michele Giuttari is a real-life Italian policeman, head of the Squadra Mobile for around 8 years in his own right, so it's not too much of a stretch to believe that his central protagonist, Michele Ferrara, is more than a little autobiographical.  The author has allowed his character to be slightly quirky, but undoubtedly he is the hero of the piece, and given the cases that Giutarri investigated, including the Monster of Florence, the reader has to assume that some of the events aren't that far from real life as well.  

As the bodies are found, seemingly pointlessly ... Read Review

Bankrupts and Bandits, Frederick Guilhaus

12/09/2008 - 11:15am

There has been a slowly bubbling sub-genre of crime fiction based in the financial world that seems to have been going on for ages in Australia, and every now and then you'll fall across one of those books - normally in a second hand shop now.  I can't remember where I spied BANKRUPTS AND BANDITS or even when for that matter, but it was sitting on my pile of unread local authors when I grabbed it the other day.

I confess I'm not much interested in finance - high finance, bankruptcy, losing the business or anything else much to do with money (shocking isn't it) so I tend ... Read Review

Into the Darklands and Beyond, Nigel Latta

11/09/2008 - 1:12pm

Nigel Latta did a session at the Crime & Justice Festival earlier this year, that to be brutally honest, we all ended up attending more by good luck than our own good judgement (the session we'd booked was cancelled) so we switched.  I can't remember the last time I felt so lucky to switch to a session about subject matter that so isn't something you want to think about.  Not only does Nigel Latta make you think - he makes you laugh - he makes you squirm uncomfortably - he makes you just a bit weepy at points.  Mostly he makes you glad that there are people like him doing the ... Read Review

Pitcairn: Paradise Lost, Kathy Marks

10/09/2008 - 12:00pm

I confess that my knowledge of the history of Pitcairn was sketchy to say the least.  I hope I knew slightly more of the history of the place than would have been gleaned from movies about the Bounty, but certainly I knew close enough to nothing about how the community was faring in the current day world, how it functioned for all those years, the nature of the life on Pitcairn, the difficulties in getting onto and off the island and so on.  I remember reports of the child rape trials that were conducted at the time, but again, my knowledge was minimal, so this book came as an ... Read Review

Pages