The Nancys, R.W.R. McDonald

Reviewed By
Karen Chisholm

Hands up those of us who thought we'd grow up to be Nancy Drew, although I will confess I was more in the Trixie Belden camp. But those books, The Secret Seven, The Famous Five and the Three Investigators series probably had a lot to do with anybody around our age addicted to mysteries, thrillers and crime fiction. Although I doubt anybody quite expected the homage that is THE NANCYS by Kiwi-Australian writer R.W.R. McDonald. And potential readers should be warned - this is not a book you'd be giving to your average 8 year old. Unless you're of a particularly broad mind and even then you may find yourself in some complicated explanation situations.

THE NANCYS, in short, is the story of when 11 year old Tippy Chan, Uncle Pike and his new boyfriend Devon solve a murder in the small New Zealand town in which Tippy and her mother Helen (Pike's sister) live. It's the same town where Pike grew up, the town he left as a young man, thinking his sexuality wasn't small town living compatible. It's the town where Helen married and lived with Tippy's father until his recent death, and now, after Helen has headed off on a much needed vacation, Tippy, Pike and Devon (henceforth known as The Nancys) investigate the violent murder of Tippy's teacher, and the accident that put one of her best friends in hospital, in a coma.

THE NANCYS is part detective story, part family saga, part small-town expose, with a hefty dose of extrovert gay culture and introvert or flat out odd local behaviour. There's the weirdo's next door, the local beauty pageant, an empty house and a pushy real-estate agent, the derelict hospital, the single traffic light (where the body was found), the problems in keeping in touch via Skype from an ocean going cruise, a young girl struggling with the reasons behind her beloved father's death and her mother's anger, the dive off a bridge taken by her friend that put him in the coma, her best friend and his family, the girl next door, the weirdness of the town, and nail polish in bright colours. It's over the top, it's reeking with banter and in-jokes, it's slightly smutty, slightly absurd, often times a little repetitive, and it's funny. It's definitely not subtle funny, sometimes it's hilarious funny, at other time's it's going to make you squirm. Individually the three main characters here, The Nancys, are interesting and together they are a sort of slightly off colour, slightly weird group of colleagues, with very unusual workplace conditions. Tippy, Pike and Helen however are a classic family grouping with tensions, and aggravations and love and support and a strong desire to kill each other at points. The affection that Tippy has for her Uncle Pike is immediately obvious, and it's touching the way that she connects to, and worries about Devon's role in her life into the future. 

This isn't classic crime fiction pacing though, so settle in for a lot of byways, highways, and laneways. You'll be working through a fair bit of set up, and you'll be reading a lot about pasts and futures, about life in a small town when you're not one of the same, when it might appear that small towns have their own array of "not the same" as most other locations. 

At the core of it though, this is character driven and Tippy's very engaging, Uncle Pike's funny and caring and Devon can bring his design stylings to our neck of the woods any day he likes. In the end THE NANCYS solve the crime, give the girl a chance to work through the highs and lows of life, and keep friends reasonably close. It's a mystery, wrapped up in a family rubbing along, in a small town where everyone's an individual, except they aren't.


THE NANCYS has been shortlisted for the 2020 Ngaio Marsh Award for Best and Best First Novel.


The entire shortlist for the 2020 Ngaio Marsh Award for Best First Novel is:

Tugga's Mob, Stephen Johnson
Aue, Becky Manawatu (also shortlisted for Best Novel)
The Nancys, R.W.R. McDonald (also shortlisted for Best Novel)
Into the Void, Christina O'Reilly

The entire shortlist for the 2020 Ngaio Marsh Award for Best Novel is:

Whatever It Takes, Paul Cleave
Girl From The Treehouse, Gudrun Frerichs
Aue, Becky Manawatu (also shortlisted for Best First Novel)
The Nancys, R.W.R. McDonald (also shortlisted for Best First Novel)
In The Clearing, J.P. Pomare
The Wild Card, Renee



Year of Publication
Book Number (in series)

A schoolgirl and her uncle and his boyfriend have two weeks to solve a murder in a small town style forgot…

'A delight - moving and hilarious. I loved every minute I spent with these characters.' - Paddy O'Reilly, author of The Wonders 

Tippy Chan is eleven and lives in a small town in a very quiet part of the world - the place her Uncle Pike escaped from the first chance he got as a teenager. Now Pike is back with his new boyfriend Devon to look after Tippy while her mum's on a cruise.

Tippy is in love with her uncle's old Nancy Drew books, especially the early ones where Nancy was sixteen and did whatever she wanted. She wants to be Nancy and is desperate to solve a real mystery. When her teacher's body is found beside Riverstone's only traffic light, Tippy's moment has arrived. She and her minders form The Nancys, a secret amateur detective club. 

But what starts as a bonding and sightseeing adventure quickly morphs into something far more dangerous. A wrongful arrest, a close call with the murderer, and an intervention from Tippy's mum all conspire against The Nancys. But regardless of their own safety, and despite the constant distraction of questionable fashion choices in the town that style forgot, The Nancys know only they can stop the killer from striking again.

The Nancys is gripping and glorious, a heart-warming novel for anyone who's ever felt they were on the outside looking in. At its heart it is about the family we make and how we must summon the courage to face the truth, no matter what the cost may be. 

Blog Through the eyes of children: debut tales win Ngaio Marsh Awards
Karen Chisholm
Monday, November 2, 2020
Review The Nancys, R.W.R. McDonald
Karen Chisholm
Monday, June 17, 2019

Add new comment

This is a book review site, with no relationship whatsoever with any of the authors mentioned here.

We do not provide a method for you to contact authors for any reason and comments of this nature are automatically deleted.

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.