Murder at Myall Creek, Mark Tedeschi

Reviewed By
Karen Chisholm

Following on from Terry Smythe's Denny Day Mark Tedeschi QC picks up the story of the aftermath of the Myall Creek Massacre, concentrating on events and the participants around the trial of the perpetrators of the massacre of 28 Aboriginal men, women and children in 1838 in northern New South Wales.

The cover of the book refers to it as the "trial that defined a nation" and it's hard not to agree 100% with that statement. Whilst it could be said that the book concentrates considerably more on the outcomes and surrounding civil changes that occurred at the time of the trial - rather than the massacre itself - it's important to realise that out of the dreadful acts of eleven men, some good eventuated including modern-day civil rights, equality, religious freedoms and the secular state. That doesn't hold true, unfortunately, for recognition of the lives lost in the massacre itself and we should never forget that or them.

The circumstances and events surrounding this massacre are utterly appalling. These killers behaved appallingly. Their crimes were beyond appalling and we should all be aware of what they did, and the manner in which they did it. We should also remember that this trial came at a time when it was virtually unknown for Europeans to be charged with any crimes against Aboriginal people. As a consequence, some small amount of justice was achieved. Awareness was raised, and good people were able to stand up for what is right.

At the heart of these people is a most fascinating man I'd never heard of. The Attorney General of New South Wales at the time - John Hubert Plunkett is a study all to himself, a religious man who believed fervently in the separation of church and State; the provision of secular education; the provision of health care to all regardless of religious background; equality before the law; emancipation; and fair and decent treatment of all people regardless of their backgrounds. 

The fact that Plunkett persisted with two trials of the alleged murderers is a relief. What he also did for the society in which we now live is worth knowing. 

Year of Publication

One of the most shocking murder trials in Australia's legal history, and the tribulations of the man who conducted it

In 1838, eleven convicts and former convicts were put on trial for the brutal murder of 28 Aboriginal men, women and children at Myall Creek in New South Wales. The trial created an enormous amount of controversy because it was almost unknown for Europeans to be charged with the murder of Aborigines. It would become the most serious trial of mass murder in Australia’s history.

The trial’s prosecutor was the Attorney General of New South Wales, John Hubert Plunkett. It proved to be Plunkett’s greatest test, as it pitted his forensic brilliance and his belief in equality before the law against the combined forces of the free settlers, the squatters, the military, the emancipists, the newspapers, and even the convict population.

From the bestselling author of Kidnapped and EugeniaMurder at Myall Creek follows the journey of the man who who arguably achieved more for modern-day civil rights in Australia than anyone else before or since.

Review Murder at Myall Creek, Mark Tedeschi
Karen Chisholm
Thursday, November 29, 2018
Blog #amreading Murder At Myall Creek, Mark Tedeschi
Karen Chisholm
Monday, June 26, 2017

Add new comment

This is a book review site, with no relationship whatsoever with any of the authors mentioned here.

We do not provide a method for you to contact authors for any reason and comments of this nature are automatically deleted.

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.