TOOTH AND CLAW - Nigel McCrery

Review Written By
Karen Chisholm

DCI Mark Lapslie is one of those grumpy, rumpled detective characters, with a slight twist.  He has synaesthesia - sounds instantly trigger taste sensations.  Which makes participating in the world profoundly difficult.  The condition is so out of control that he's had to move to an isolated cottage, communicating with his colleagues via technology, keeping the noise at bay so that he can at least function a little.  His wife has left him, taking their children with her, he's lonely, fraught, struggling to cope with the condition and the restrictions it places on his life.

Carl Whittley is lonely and bitter, struggling to cope with the reality of being sole carer for his invalid father.  While he's doing the cooking, cleaning, colostomy bag changing, and all the personal care, his mother has left and is pursuing her career as a forensic psychologist.  In some ways it makes a lot of sense that Carl's planning his third murder very early on in the book.

That last observation isn't much of a spoiler as McCrery doesn't write whodunnit style books, rather they are more an exploration of why.  Why Carl Whittley would torture a glamorous TV presenter to death, blow up some poor innocent bloke in a railway station, and still be planning more mayhem.  Why Mark Lapslie would try to stick with his job of Police DCI in the face of a personal disability that makes his every hour a nightmare.  And one of the biggest mysteries?  Why Lapslie's Chief Superintendent would think that putting him in charge of two seemingly unconnected events would provide the media pressure straw that would finally break Lapslie's back and remove him from the police force once and for all.

The synaesthesia aspects of the Lapslie series are the obvious hook that makes them different from other British, grumpy, rumpled, cynical and rather world-weary detective stories.  The other difference is that idea of the who being known by the reader up front, and the books being less of a journey to the discovery, and more a look at the characters, their motivations, and ultimately, the way in which the detective get's the bloke the reader already knows all about.  There's often traces of quite black humour in this series as well, although in this particular book you'll have to dig a little deeper to find it, and you may also need to have a fairly high tolerance for graphic descriptions.  To be frank, there's very little about Carl and his activities that can be explained, or even vaguely quantified, and at the same time there's something rather bleak about the dogged way in which Lapslie pursues his perpetrator.

Not that TOOTH AND CLAW itself is bleak, this is really a very readable, absorbing and interesting entrant in a series that is definitely well worth pursing.  I suspect it is, however, one of those series that would be best read in order, as the way that Lapslie's synaesthesia affects his life, his ability to do his job, and everyone around him does ebb and flow, and you need to understand how that all works to get an understanding of him overall.

The series in order:

Still Waters (aka Core of Evil)
Tooth and Claw

Year of Publication
Book Number (in series)

Carl Whittley is at home.  He's twenty-two and charged with caring for his crippled father.  It's not much of a life but he has plenty of distractions.  He's just tortured a sexy, young TV presenter to death and he's planning to blow an anonymous commuter to pieces.

DCI Mark Lapslie is at home too.  He suffers from a rare neurological condition that has forced him to leave his family and to avoid the police station.  Already, he is building a reputation amongst his superiors as a nuisance to be avoided - either that or a lunatic.

The strange spate of brutal, apparently inexplicable, deaths has caught the media's attention and the Chief Superintendent is at a loss.  He brings in Lapslie, knowing this case could be enough to break him.  The press will have their lamb for the slaughter and he will be free of the troublesome DCI.

But he hasn't quite got the measure of Lapslie.  The deadly game Carl wants to play might be just what Lapslie needs to come out of hiding.

Review TOOTH AND CLAW - Nigel McCrery
Karen Chisholm
Friday, February 10, 2012
Blog Currently Reading - Tooth and Claw, Nigel McCrery
Karen Chisholm
Sunday, March 14, 2010

Add new comment

This is a book review site, with no relationship whatsoever with any of the authors mentioned here.

We do not provide a method for you to contact authors for any reason and comments of this nature are automatically deleted.

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.