Currently Reading - Who Killed Scott Guy?, Mike White

Flagged as the case that gripped a nation, it's not one that I'd heard of on this side of the ditch, before starting this book. Seems like a very sad series of events all round.

From the Blurb:

Scott Guy was a good man, a great dad, a salt-of-the-earth farmer who was gunned down at his front gate for no conceivable reason.

His death enthralled us, partly because it was so inexplicable, but also because there were no obvious suspects. When police finally arrested someone, public fascination soared - because the person they claimed killed Scott Guy was his brother-in-law, colleague and former mate, Ewen Macdonald.

While on the surface a hardworking husband and father of four, it gradually emerged Macdonald had an alter-ego and alternative life of violence and retribution. The police case against him seemed so logical: Ewen Macdonald was aggrieved, anxious and angry - and secretly hated the person who'd been best man at his wedding, Scott Guy. So Macdonald meticulously planned to get rid of Scott and shot him as he headed to work.

But despite enormous media coverage, the reality is that most of us still know very little about the case. To understand what really happened and why it happened, you need to set aside what you think you know and start over again, from the beginning, from that first dark midwinter morning.


You are clearly a conspiracy theorist. The book is appalling - When confronted with a psycopath, people just don't see reality. MacDonald just lies effortlessly. The book just doesn't confront the obvious. I'd like to know what Nigel Latta thinks -

Normally I just let these sorts of comments disappear into the primordial slime from whence they came but recent events have made me think sod it, I'm sick of being attacked by wankers.

"You are clearly a conspiracy theorist". WTF are you smoking? Not even posted, mind you, on the review of the book, but a mention that I'm reading it. Fine if you want to have an opinion on the case - but don't come round here chucking anonymously created insults at somebody who is reading a bloody book about the case.

Post new comment